....    page 1 of 5 pages   |   www.unifon.org/36fonems.html  |    1   23   4   5  | phonemes-44  |  No. of phonemes  |
|  Download  free Georgia Ref font to view page  |   44 english    |   Next >> 
36 Fonemes
14 pure vowels, 22 consonants
 The Graphic Representation of Speech
A pronunciation guide for English should recognize the 
36 pure phonemes and be isomorphic with IPA.  Communication systems can merge and abbreviate since native speakers do not need a full set of cues. 
see visible speech
  For a  version with more graphics - click here >graphics
Pronunciation Guide
Listsof the phonemes of English.
14uncombined vowels, 22 consonants
IPAvowels
An orthgraphicchallenge
The limitationsof the IPA effort for general communication.
Sampletranscription
Symbolsfor phonemes
teach yourself linguistics
linguisticatlas LINKS

adckwct prcnxnsEAScn gIdz for ENgliS ~ addaquat pronunncieishan gaidz  for English
Adequate pronunciation guides  for English must recognize at least 36 uncombined phonemes [14 v-22 c]. The issue is how to best represent these 36 sound segments: [1] what is the best letter choice for a phonogram and [2] what sounds, if any, can be merged or combined.  Writing systems do not have to be pronunciation guides.  The traditional one certainly isn't. 

For those who know the language, a much abbreviated code could be used.  The common practice is to reduce the number of vowels by four.  Perhaps the reduction can be double this. Most systems do not try to abbreviate the consonants. However, if abbreviation is the goal, consonant reduction should also be considered.

This page does not explore the possibilities of abbreviated writing systems for native speakers.  The focus is on the minimum phoneme set required for a description of English speech.  The orthographic challenge is to build a system that can be used by a non-speaker to code the language which can then be used by another non-speaker to transcribe and read aloud [comprehension not required]. The goal is a writing system or graphical transcription system that can be coded with letters, decoded into speech, and understood by a native speaker with 95% accuracy. 

The chart below shows the 14 pure vowels in yellow nad the 22 pure consonants in teal and green.  There are three consonants that do not have a symbol [dh/th] [zh] and [ng] and two that are not pure consonants that do [j] and [ch]. 


http://groups.yahoo.com/group/truespel/files/48_phonograms-exploded.gif

43rye.gif

THE ORTHOGRAPHIC CHALLENGE
 
 
 
 

all notations here show stress
abbot abut
abaat ubbut 
'ae-b't '-'bLht
abbat abutt 
aebxt xbat
abxt xbVt


Three step process: 1. encode speech, 2, decode and pronounce, 3. interpret the acoustic productions.  Native speakers using a traditional writing system can easily do this with 95% accuracy.  The challenge is to do it with non-native speakers at stages 1 and 2. 

One of the first steps to be established would be a base line.  This could be done with highly phonemic writing systems such as Spanish.  Two students would learn the sound-symbol correspondences. The first would listent to a native speaker read a short paragraph.  This could be done slowly and each word could be pronounced twice.  This transcription would be handed to a second student who would try to convert the letter sequences into speech.  The speech would be recorded by another literate native speaker.  The starting paragraph and the two transcriptions would be compared and the errors at each stage recorded.  The hypothesis: 95% of the text would remain intact. 

This is a version of the gossip game where a story is whispered into one person's ear who in turn whispers it to someone else.  At the end of the chain, the original story is compared to the ending story to see to what extent it has been simplified, embellished and changed.
 

Table of Contents    -    Related Links 
principles of spelling reform  |  absurdities of the traditional writing system | links

The list of phonemes

21 vowels with 14 pure phonemes were isolated over 100 years ago. Bishop Wilkins provided a sophisticated analysis of speech sounds in 1650.  It is the work of Pitman and Ellis, however, that linguists found to be the most relevant. These became part of the International Phonetic Alphabet. People did try to write in this notation but it was rarely as easy as ABC. IPA looked odd, used special characters requiring a special font, and could not be read without a key by the untrained.

The typography for IPA was refined once by Goody's for the SSA font.  The new design was quite successful from an aesthetic standpoint but never caught on. Dewey [1971] used this font in his books on spelling frequency.

The traditional IPA turned characters are now included in unicode but it remains a rather ugly typeface. The symbols never became part of Latin-1 so it remains a difficult system to type unless the receiving party has the SIL or UNICODE IPA font installed. There is still a problem with the location of the keys associated with the special characters. 

The problems with IPA can be listed as follows:

1. ugly looking combination of special characters and rotated characters which
   looks OK for pronunciation guides in dictionaries but not for large blocks of text
   Sweet's broad romic notation system below is perhaps the best looking version of ipa.
2. no uniform location for the various special characters on the keybaord
  Unifon II uses an inutitive sound sign location to access a variation of Sweet's romic.
3. not taught outside of ESL classes and linguistics departments
4. usually requires a key for interpretation or identification of the word being referenced

Is there an IPA equivalent with a more appealing appearance on the page, which is easier to read and to type?  Could such a code be developed?  Goody's SSA typeface showed that the aesthetics could be improved.  The new face, however, was no easier to type and probably only slightly easier to read than IPA. 
 
UnifOn 2 - korespqndcns tAbcl Correspondence Table
short
long
compound
r-compound
[at, add] q [are, alms] I /ai/ [ice, eye] qr [are] ar Ir
e [el, edj] c [ago, sofa] A /ei/ [ape] er [air, care there]
i [it, ill] E [eel, he] oi [oil boy] ir [ear, irrate]
q Q[odd] o [awed] O [ode, oat] or [for, tore]
v [hook put] u [gvru] U [you, Use Uz] ur [poor, tour]
x up xpcr R [herder] au  [out cow] aur [our, tower]
In GA odd is pronounced aad or qd.  In RP it is Qp or closer to awed.
 

There have been digraphic versions of IPA such as Spanglish.  While there is a phonemic version of Spanglish without the X, and C, these characters are often needed to maintain "eye rhymes" with traditionally spelled words: [catt for kaet, faxx for faeks]Spanglish also includes the schwi [unstressed /i:/] which Jones considered to be redundant.  The chart on right shows 14 yellowish pure vowels the same number as displayed in the ipa chart above.  When the green and blue cells are added, the number of vowels corresponds to ipa's 21 essential vowels.  The three green cells contain diphthongs.  The four blue cells contain R or schwa combinations.

The table on the right shows the 14 pure vowels in yellow tinted cells and the 22 pure consonants in the right half of the chart.  The cells coded in dark blue contain combined consonants. This minimum set of 36 phonemes is recognized by everyone. Different dialects of English will disagree on how to apply this phoneme set. American's will tend to replace the short o with aa as in bother /baather/.  Australians will tend to pronounce DAY as it is spelled while Americans will pronounce the word /dei/. 

It takes some time to unpack this info-graphic.  When done, one has a mnemonic for thie entire Saxon Spanglish system.  It will allow a person to spell any word in English with almost 100% predictability. If you can pronounce it you can spell it in any phonemic system with one and only one symbol for each important sound. The result rarely looks much like English.  A consistent system will respell 60% of the words in the language. 

If one wants both standardized spelling and pronunciation guide spelling, a decision has to be made regarding the dialect that will be sound spelled.  Different pronunciations result in different spellings.

Does everyone agree that these are the 14 pure vowels.  This does not mean that your orthography cannot merge some of them.  This is just a question about understanding and recognition. 

For american speakers, the short o is a redundnat phoneme.  bottle is pronounced baatl.  This can be confirmed at the M-Webster website where bottle is written ba:t&l

The typical mergers are ^ and @ - the stressed and unstressed versoion of the same sound.  ^ is slightly more rounded that the schwa.  In some systems murder is written murdur or mrdr, merging 3r and @r.  These simplifications are OK in an informal writing system but they eliminate phonemes that carry a low semantic load. 

Critieria for an adequate pronunciation guide spelling system


14  P U R E   V O W E L S
This chart of four alternate notations provides a key word for each vowel sound.

The 14 pure vowels are shown on the left.
Add 22 consonants to reach the minimum number of uncombined pure phonemes - 36.

Jones included 3 diphthongs ai, oi, au.
and 4 @ combinations.
resulting in a minimum phonogram list of 43.

The two consonants missing are wh and kh.

25 consonants
bCdDfghjkK
lmnNprsStTvw
WyzZ

Chart 40 U2

 

 

24 C O N S O N A N T S  [in progress]  see rye's list of 43 phonemes and 
see sounds of letters
Symbol pair Articulatory Definitions Example PG
b
c
d
D
f
g
j
h
j
k
l
l
L
m
n
N

r
R
s
S
t
T
v
w
z
Z
g
j
t
T
v
b
C
voiced bilabial plosive stop
unv palatal assibilate stop
bib
ChurCh
bIb
CRC

Phonemic Transcriptions:  IPA is the most popular code for dictionary pronunciation guides. Normally it looks rather odd when used for more than a couple of words.   Sweet's version below is quite attractive.  The version where he replaces the eth [ð] with the Greek delta is even better.  Spanglish, one of several ASCII-IPA notations compatible with e-mail, is an IPA  equivalent that uses no special characters or diacritics.  It is supposed to look less alien than IPA.  Please write and tell me [sbett@lycos.com ] if it achieves its aesthetic goal and if you could read it without a key.
IPA-International Phonetic Alphabet SS- Saxon-Spanglish Fonemic Notation
W'ns 'pon ' taim ð' bjutif'l do:t' 'v '
greit m'd3iò'n want'd mo:': p':lz tu: put 'm'h h': tre3ju':z."Luk thru: ð' sent': 'v  ð' mu:n hwen it iz blu:," sed h'r m'th' in æns': tu: h': kwestò'n, "Ju: mait faind j': ha':tz di:zair."
Wans apon a taim the [dha] biutifal doter av a
greit majishan waanted mor perlz tu put amang her treazherz."Luk thru the center av the muun hwen itt izz blu," sedd her mather inn aenser tu her queschan, "Yu mait faind yer haartz dizair."
^wcns cpon c tIm Dc bUtifcl dotcr cv c grEt mcjiScn wqntcd mor pcrlz tu pvt cmcN hcr treZurz, ^"Luk thru Dc sentcr cv Dc mun Wen it iz blu, "sed hcr mcDcr in anscr tu hcr kwesCcn, ^"U mIt fInd ycr hqrtz dizIr.   keyboard Unifon2 a possible font corrected lower case [downsized] unifon.  Unifon means one sound per symbol

-w'ns 'pon ' tYm ð' butif'l dot'r 'v ' grEt m'jiò'n want'd mor p'rlz tu pvt cmcN h'r treZurz, "-Luk thru ð' sent'r 'v ð' mun Wen it iz blu, "sed h'r m'ðcr in ans'r tu h'r kwesò'n, "U mYt fYnd y'r hartz dizYr.     Unifont2
 


Nonsense story containing all 36 phonemes of English in three transcriptions
RITE reduced irregularity
Saxon Spanglish [digraphic]
Unifon 2[monoliteral]
I peepd at the taat hu was kicking his fat thie so sherly that the cherch paster sed; 'Yay, I hav hung the bells and thay shall toll for the mime, If yu bring me an egg and sum ash on wul.' Without ferther adu, the faathers sed they aar up in the air, in dissaray, eevan Ian, with his ded bib and the gag. Tho hi voud nevver tu mezher or judj enny animal av the zu.  Lest woe bifaul him and thay roar at him or eeven eet him. Better if thay eet ice, oaks, oil, or uuz.  He erjd aul av them, grasping hiz eer and kicking a yu [yew]. aI piepd at the taat hu waz kicking hiz faet thhai so shurrly thaet the cherch passter sed; 'Yey, aI havv hunng the bellz and they shall toal for the maim, If yu bring mi an egg and summ ash on wul.' Without furrther adu, the faatherz sed they aar upp in the eir, in disarey, ievan Ain, with hiz dead bib aend the gag. Tho hi voud nevver tu mezher or judj enny annimal av the zu.  Lest wo bifol him aend they roar at him or ieven iet him.  Better if they iet ais, oaks, oil, or uuz.  Hi urrjd ol av them, graesping hiz ir and kicking a yu [yew]. I pEpt at Dc tqt hu wcz kikiN hiz fat TI so Surly Dat Dc CRC pastcr sed, "yA, I hav hcng Dc belz and thA Sal tol for Dc mIm.  if U bring mE an eg and scm aS on wul." withaut fRthcr cdu, the fqdcr sed thA qr xp in Di er.  in discrA, Evcn Icn, with hiz ded bib and Dc gag. thO hE vaud nevcr tu meZcr or juj eny animcl cv Dc zu.  lest wO bifol him and thA rOr at him or Evcn Et him.  betcr if thA Et Is, Oks, oil, or uz.  hE Rjd ol cv Dem, graspiN hiz ir and kikiN c U [yu].


The 14 vowels in different orthographies  [foneme-symbols]

Key    Truespel   Unifon  Uni2  Spanglish   Ian     m-w    ChK
---    ----       ----    ----  ---------   ----    ----   ----
at     at         at      at    aet att     ct      at 
el     el         el      el    ell         el      el 
it     it         it      it    itt         it      it
odd GA aad        od      qd    odd         aad*    a:d
odd RP aud        xd*     Qd    od          od      od
hook   ook        Ck      vk    huk wk      huk     huk
up     up         up     'cp xp upp vp ap   ap     '&p
----
are    aar        or      qr    aar         aar     a:r
ago    uggoe      cgO     cgO   ago         agou    &gO
herd   herd       hurd    hRd   hurrd       h3d     h&rd
ace    aes        As      As    eis         eis     As
eel    eel        El      El    iel         jl iil  El
awe    au         x       o     ao   o      oo      o
or     or         xr      or    or          or      or 
owe    oe         O       O     oa          ou      O
ooze   uez        uz      uz    uuz         uuz     u:z
use    yuez       Yz      Uz    yuuz        yuuz    yu:z
---------------------------------------------------------
out    out        qt      aut   out aut     aut     aut
boy    boi        bQ      boi   boi boy     boi     boi



A British pronunciation dictionary will not be identical to one for General American
The main differences will be [rhotic/non-rhotic], [short o], and the distribution of [aa].

I rather also like the Q for awe.

o = the British short o   thA bOth tvk c both
q = the free vowel aa  as in palm [paam]
Q = o:  as in bought
O = &u  as in boat

Hi taot the tott and the boy.    Spanglish 
hE tQt Dc tqt and Dc boi.      U2 revised
hE txt Dc tot and Dc bQ.       Unifon 1
 

Positional Cues:  E is a schwa before or after an R and at the end of a syllable.
ragaard is speled regaard in Spanglish
athar is spelled other [utther and vthar are too complicated or odd looking]

ear cuts vs. eye cuts
Cut SS             Cut Spelling
pressin              presng
prezznt             presnt
prizn                 prisn
dezurrt             dessert   the after meal treat or [v] to leave
dezzrt               desrt      an arid place
prefurr              prefr
prefferans         preference

How do yu pronounce:  ta te ti to tu?

How do you pronounce  at et it ot ut 

How do you pronounce ata eta ita ota uta

agr  egr  igr  ogr  ugr

move to sounds of letters [letter sounds]. [letter-names]
 
Letters and Associated Sounds
Letter
lst sound
2nd sound
3rd saund
overlaps
combinations
R-comb.
a
/a:/  alms
a   /'/  ago
ae   ash at
ae, 'a, ei, o
ai, au, aw
ar  are
e
e   /e / el
ei/ey  they
'e, 'er  /'/ herder
'r  'a
ei ew eu eau
/er/ eric, air 
i
/I/ bit, ill
/i:/ beat, eel
/ai/  my mice
schwa-schwi
ia iu via few
ir /ir/  ear
o
awe
owe
haat  hot
au, ou, aa
ow, oa
or  ow'r
u
guru pool
put book
up cut  / L /
u, ^, 3:  w
 ou, iu, eu
ur  tour
u
u   / L up
ur murder
y
yellow
very verry
b
/b/ bib
/v/
/p/ 
debt
bl, bq, br
b'rg  berg
c
/k/ cut
/s/ circl
ch /tsh/ cello
k, s, ch, sh
ci, ce, ca, co
c'rd curd
d
/d/
/dh/
t
dh
da de di du
d'r'abl 
f
/f/
/v/
--
v
fif of ofn
f'r 

 

Homonym Defined

Homophones are words of different meanings which are pronounced the same, 
regardless of whether they are spelled identically or differently.

Homographs are words of different meanings which are spelled the same, 
regardless of whether they are pronounced identically or differently.

So, for example:

'bear' and 'bare' are homophones but not homographs.

'lead' (the metal) and 'lead' (the verb, as in "Where will this lead us?") 
are homographs, but not homophones.

'bear' (the animal) and 'bear' (the verb, as in "I can't bear this") are 
both homophones and homographs.

In linguistics, when we use 'homonym' at all, we commonly use it as a cover 
term for both homophones and homographs: words which are *either* 
homophones *or* homographs (or both) are homonyms.  In this terminology, 
then, all three of my pairs are pairs of homonyms, though of different 
kinds.

But dictionaries do not always report linguistic usage, and it seems clear 
that dictionaries do some funny things with the term 'homonym'.  Your 
Merriam-Webster defines 'homonym' as meaning 'one of two words which are 
both homophones and homonyms' -- a use I have seldom encountered, and one 
which I would not want to encourage.  I've just checked two other good 
dictionaries.  Collins gives 'one of two words which are either homophones 
or homographs' -- the linguistic use.  American Heritage gives just 
'homophone'.



Ian wrote:
May I return tu the four examples I gave ... and will now expand: 
NB:      'q' is redifined as TES  'ng'  loqiq (longing)
      '3'  is redefined as TES  'er' (fern)
      '2'  is redefined as  TES 'sh' fi2iq (fishing)
WorldEnglish    TES
HAT  ...   ...    ..     hut
Example:   Samwan amaq as hcz sam mani tu bai sam hani.
                  Someone among us has some money to buy some honey.

HAAT  ....   ...     heart
Example:      Faama Klaak tuk hiz kaa tu maaket cnd eit a 2aak-b3ga.
      Farmer Clark took his car to market and ate a shark-burger.
      (Yes, hj woz haqgri).  [Yes he was hungry]

HCT  ...   ...  ..     hat
Example      A fct blck kct geiv t2eis tu a fct blck rct on 4a mct.
      A fat black cat gave chase tu a fat black rat on the mat.

HEIT ....   .....    hate
Example:      Keit eit h3 meit ct eit.
      Kate ate her mate at eight. (She was a punctual spider).

Pavle ... it is vital thct yuu andastcnd the abav points.

Criteria for an adeuqate system of graphic representation of the sounds of speech. not here

syllabicssaxon-alfa- saxon-span - how many

Links

  http://babel.uoregon.edu/Yamada/fonts/croatian.html
  © 2000 BETA Information Design