Kabah -- Hzt. Ali's Birthplace & the QUR?ANIC Truth versus akbaraLLy
mehERally's falsehood and distortion of scriptural--material facts! 1 of
2

BISMILLAAHIR RAHMAANIR RAHIIM
 IN THE NAME OF ALLAH, RAHMAN, RAHIIM

002.144
1.      We have seen the turning of thy face to HEAVEN (for guidance,
O Muhammad).
2.      And now verily WE SHALL MAKE THEE TURN toward a

                __QIBLAH WHICH IS DEAR TO THEE.__

3.      So TURN thy FACE toward the MASJIDIL-HARAAM, and ye,
wheresoever ye may be, TURN your FACES toward it. Lo!

CONTINUED:

Fatimah told them that in her plight she had prayed and pleaded to
God for help and to provide her shelter to give birth to her child.
When she saw the walls split apart. She cowered in fear. But four
beautifull Ladies within spoke softly to her, and told her not be
afraid and that Allah(swt) had heard her prayer and so they invited
me in. She said as soon she entered. The holy walls behind her
closed and she was helped by the Ladies in her ordeal and she gave
birth to her new born son. Angels handed down to the Ladies water
and they cleaned her and her baby and prepared clothes for the
small infant. For three days she ate and slept in peace in the
presence of the holy Ladies.

At that point Mohammad Al-Ameen(pbuh&hf) with his two uncles Abu
Taleb, Abbass and Hamzah arrived at the scene. Mohammad(pbuh&hf)
stood before Fatimah Bint Assad his foster mother and streched out
his arms and tooked the small child from her and smiled warmly
down at him.

The mother then proudly stated that she would name him Haider
meaning 'Lion', but Mohammad(pbuh&hf) instead renamed him as Ali
(as). He explained to Fatimah that he was instructed by Allah(swt).
A name no one before him had ever been named before, and Fatimah
Bint Al-Assad rejoiced and thank Allah(swt) for His true Blessing
and help. Till this very day the miracle split of the stone blocks
of The  Kabah wall is clearly visible.
 

                 -x-x-x-x-x  VERSUS  -x-x-x-x-x
 

akbaraLLy mehERally's falsehood and distortion of material facts:

http://www3.bc.sympatico.ca/trust/underis6.htm
Conviction No. 2:

   'Facing Qibla is not a fundamental principal of Islam" Ismailis
 do not face in the direction of Mecca, the Islamic Qibla, while
reciting their ritual prayers. To uphold and support their Unique
 Belief Al-Waiz (missionary) Abualy writes:

  "Facing Qibla in prayer is not a fundamental principle of Islam,
it is a tradition." 'Ismaili Tariqah' page 184

  Is the command of Allah a tradition? Is not obedience to the
Command of Allah the most fundamental principle of Islam? What
would happen if Ismaili missionaries were to propagate that
obedience  to the Command of Aga Khan is not a fundamental
principle of Ismailism?

         Allah Commands:

    "From whencesoever thou startest forth (for prayer????, navali)
turn thy  face in the direction of the Sacred Mosque: That is indeed
the truth from thy Lord. And Allah is not unmindful of what  ye do.
So from whencesoever thou startest forth, turn thy face in the
direction of the Sacred Mosque; among wheresoever ye are turn your
face thither: That there be no ground of dispute against you among
the people, except those of them that are bent on wickedness; so
fear them not, but   fear Me; and that I may complete My favours
on you, and ye may be guided". Holy Quran 2/149-150
--------

[NAVALI: WHEN DID ALLAH MAKE THIS COMMAND RE: THE PRAYER????]

         Belief No. 8:

         Tawaf of Kabah made obligatory because of Ali!

         Below is an extract from 'Ismaili Tariqah', page 208:-

    "An eminent Sunni scholar of Nishapur, Maulvi Lutfullah Nishapuri
(d. 180 A.H.) wrote:
                        (A poem in Persian)

         Translation by Abualy:

      "The circumambulation of the Kaba has been made obligatory for
 all (Muslims) because this is the birth place of Ali Ibn Abi Talib."

   Ismaili Ginan "Muman Chetawni" describes the birth of Ali in Kabah
as under which is no less than a fairy tale.

                (a Gujrati Ginan appears here)

         Translation:

  The mother of Ali had gone to Baitullah (Kabah) to pray. When she
rose from her worship, it was the time for the birth of Ali. She
became worried. There was not time enough to reach home. There
was another house nearby. A wall of that house instantly broke
open and became a window. She got up and entered. Two "Hurrahs"
(heavenly maids) came into the house.

  Then Ali was born. He is the "Avatar " (incarnation) of the
  Unseen, from time immemorial. "Muman Chetawni", verses 80 to 82

  History records that Ali's father was the son of Bad al-
Mutilate Ibn Hasidim, keeper of the keys of the Kabah (a
prestigious post in pre-Islamic society of Mecca). The Ginan
says, she went into another house that was nearby. It could
have been the house of the keeper her father-in-law. Anyone who
has read the history of Islam or the Quran knows that Kaba?s
significance is associated with Abraham and Ishmael and not
with Ali or his mother.
--------------

NAVALI:  Contrary to the above contention and false fabrication,
the Holy Qur?an asserts categorically that there were 2 Holy
PLACES in Mecca then. See HQ. 5:2,97.

002.144    We have seen the turning of thy face to heaven
(for guidance, O Muhammad). And now verily We shall make thee
turn toward a QIBLAH WHICH IS DEAR TO THEE. So turn thy face
toward the MASJIDIL-HARAAM,
----------

;>>

Ahadith:

1.  Ibn Mas'ud says that the Prophet said: TO LOOK UPON ALI
IS DEVOTION.

2.   Ibn Asakir on the authority of CALIPH ABU BAKR records
the Prophet said: LOOKING UPON ALI IS WORSHIP

[Non-Ismaili source: 'Ali The Magnificent, by Yousuf N. Lalljee
 [a Shia 12er- -Ithna'ashari]  pp. 251].
--------------

http://www.unn.ac.uk/societies/islamic/hadith/bukhari/074.htm

Translation of Sahih Bukhari, Book 74:
Volume 8, Book 74, Number 246:

Narrated Abu Huraira:

The Prophet said, "Allah created Adam in His picture, sixty
cubits (about 30 meters) in height. When He created him, He
said (to him), "Go and ....
--------------

NAVALI: IF THESE AHADITH ARE CORRECT AS RECORDED BY
NON-ISMAILI SOURCES THEN DOES IT NOT MEAN THAT LOOKING
UPON ALI WAS DEVOTION AND WORSHIP? IF SO, WHAT DID THE
HOLY PROPHET DO WHEN HE LOOKED UPON ALI [PBUTH]?
;>>
-----------

AND DID THE HOLY PROPHET _ALSO_ BELIEVE AND PREACH THAT
ALLAH HAD A PHYSICAL FORM?

Regardless, need we say more when this man, akbaraLLy mehERally
so blatantly belies the Holy Qur?an and the Ahadith in his dire
but futile endeavour to denigrate the Aga Khan (SA) IV and the
Ismaili Muslim Tariqah?

May Allah protect your faith and guide you to the Right Path
-- Sirataal Mustaqiim.
 

TO BE CONTINUED

Email me on:
Navali@fcmail.com