The Great Debate

My great, great, great uncle, Amariah Wilson, Sr., wrote in his Outline of the Wilson Family that "my grandfather James Wilson his name is on the Declaration of our Independence." As a result some of my cousins believe that our ancestor, James Wilson, did sign the Declaration of Independence. I believe that he was writing about family lore that he had heard somewhere. Inasmuch as Amariah did not directly state that his grandfather actually signed the Declaration of Independence, I am not convinced that he really believed it. Or, if he did believe it, he had to be in error. His own data about the Wilson family contradicts the theory that our James was the signer of the Declaration of Independence. Accordingly, I offer the following information to refute that theory:

James Wilson - the Signer of the Declaration of Independence

The above information was gathered from many online biographies of James Wilson.

_______________________________________________________________________________

James Wilson - my ancestor

This information was gathered from the writings of my gr-gr-great uncle, Amariah Wilson, Sr.

______________________________________________________________________

SUMMARY:

Our James was 12 years older than the Signer, lived with his father in America (the Signer immigrated to America after his father died in Scotland), and his children were all born in Pennsylvania years before the Signer immigrated to America. Additionally, the wives' and children's names for the two were totally different.

Back


Home


Images provided by: