Bibliography
Note from the Anonymous Typist:
The following bibliography appears more or
less as it did in the original publication of the
book. However, I don't share their appraisals; so,
I'm taking advantages of my Omnipotence as editor
to add a few embellishments here and there.
I've added a list of additional books at the
end of this bibliography.
The authors believe this bibliography to be the most
comprehensive of its kind in a book such as this for the
general reader. It includes, besides objective and critical
works on spiritualism, many hard-to-find titles on such
associated subjects as stage mentalism, carnival torture
feats, and the specific methods of fraud used by particular
mediums: for example, the "regurgitation" mediumship of
Helen Duncan.
Readers who wish to go deeply into the psychology and
psychology of spiritualistic fraud will find sufficient
leads here to launch them well on their way.
Some books in this bibliography, such as Fodor's and
Carrington's, take the view that though fraud exists,
genuine psychic phenomena also exist. This is the view of
William Rauscher, Allen Spraggett and, to a lesser extent,
Lamar Keene.
- Abbott, David P. Behind the Scenes with the Medium. Chicago: Open
Court, 1907.
- Anderson, George. "It Must Be Mind-Reading." Chicago: Ireland Magic,
1963.
- Anderson, George. "You, Too, Can Read Minds." Chicago: Magic, 1968.
- Annemann, Theodore. Practical Mental Effects. New York: Holden's Magic
Shops, 1944. Methods of revealing unknown knowledge.
- Annemann, Theodore "202 Methods of Forcing." Chicago: Magic, 1964.
- Bach, Marcus. The Will to Believe. Englewood Cliffs,N.J.: Prentice-
Hall. 1955. See Chapt. 10, "Do We Live After Death?" for account
of a materialization seance with medium Fanchion Harwood.
- Baggally, W.W. Telepathy: Genuine and Fraudulent. London: Methuen,
1922.
- Barbanell, Maurice. "Seance Room Scoundrel," Tomorrow Magazine 6, No.
3, Summer 1958: p. 49. The story of the medium William Roy.
- Barbanell, Maurice. This Is Spiritualism. London: Herbert Jenkins,
1959.
- Bayless, Raymond. Experiences of a Psychical Researcher. New Hyde
Park, N.Y.: University Books, 1972. See chapters 2, 27 and 28 on
Spiritualism, Fakers, Magicians and Mediums.
- Blackmore, Simon Augustine, S.J. Spiritism Facts and Frauds. New York:
Benziger Brothers, Printers to the Holy Apostolic See, 1924. A
tracing of spiritism from necromancy in ancient times from the
viewpoint of the Catholic Church.
- Blunsdon, Norman. A Popular Dictionary of Spiritualism. London: Arco
Publications, 1961.
- Bowers, Edwin F. Spiritualism's Challenge. New York: National Library
Press, 1936. See Chapter 14, "Honest and Dishonest Mediums," and
reports of the enigmatic mediumship of Frank Decker, with a
report on his mail-sack escape and his association with Dunninger
the magician. The checkered career of Eusapia Palladino confounds
the writer of this book. She explains to a reporter, when asked
if she has ever been caught cheating, "Many times I have been
told so. You see, it is like this. Some people are at a table who
expect tricks-- in fact, they want them. I am in a trance.
Nothing happens. They get impatient. They think of the tricks--
nothing but tricks. They put their minds on the tricks, and I--
and I automatically respond. But it is not often. They merely
will me to do them. That is all."
- Brown, Slater. The Heyday of Spiritualism. New York: Hawthorn Books,
1970. Excellent history of the early days.
- Cannell, J. C. The Secrets of Houdini. New York: Dover Publications,
1973.75
"Carnival Torture Feats." Atlanta, Ga.: Pinchpenny Press, n.d.
(mimeograph). How to perform physical feats of torture without
getting hurt-- everything from needle-jabbing and pulse control
to putting your fingers in hot lead.
- Carrington, Hereward. Sideshow and Animal Tricks. Kansas City: 1913;
Atlanta, Ga.: Pinchpenny Press, 1973.
- Carrington, Hereward. The Physical Phenomena of Spiritualism. New
York: American Universities, 1920. A critical book covering all
phases of physical phenomena and explaining many methods still in
use today.
- Carrington, Hereward Personal Experiences in Spiritualism. London: T.
Wetner Lurie, n.d.
- Christopher, Milbourne. "One Man Mental Magic." New York: Tannen
Publications, 1952.
- Christopher, Milbourne. Mediums, Mystics and the Occult. New York:
Thomas Y. Crowell Company, 1975. A famous magician attempts to
give the inside story on how to distinguish honest psychic
research methods from the charlatans that prey upon the hopes and
fears of the gullible. Well documented with many details.
- Christopher, Milbourne. Panorama of Magic. New York: Dover
Publications, 1962. See material on famous mentalists.
- Christopher, Milbourne. ESP, Seers and Psychics. New York: Thomas Y.
Crowell, 1970. Although negative toward the reality of ESP and
psychic phenomena, it does provide background material on
specific psychic personalities but gives little credit to them or
to reputable researchers. Fake methods are presented and
postulated.
- Christopher, Milbourne. The Illustrated History of Magic. New York:
Thomas Y. Crowell, 1973. Material on mind-readers and mentalists.
- Confessions of a Medium. London: Griffith, Farran, Okeden, and Welsh,
1882.
- Confessions of a Medium, Columbus, O.: Nelson Enterprises, 1969
(mimeograph). Throws a "ruthless spotlight of truth on the
grafters and frauds that infest the Spiritualistic movement and
the psychic business."
- "The Nail Writer: Swami Gimmic, 24 Astounding Effects with the
Mentalist's Miracle Gimmic, A Full Treatise on the Proper
Handling of the Nail Writer." New York: Louis Tannen, n.d.
- Corinda. Thirteen Steps to Mentalism. New York: Louis Tannen, 1968.
- Corinda, and Read, Ralph W. (Ed.) The Complete Guide to Billet-
Switching. New York: Louis Tannen, Inc., 1976; Booklet. This
clever 46 page guide reminds you to look at the spectator when
you switch a Billet-not your hands and when the spectator has
written something to say "what you are thinking" NOT "what you
have written." This work was compiled for entertainment purposes.
It is important for the student and psychic researcher for
learning the methods of billet switching so that public or
private demonstrations by mediums, psychics and "mentalists" do
not confuse and confound the sincere seeker.
- Cox, William E. "Parapsychology and Magicians." Parapsychology Review
(May-June, 1974).
- Curry, Paul. Magician's Magic. New York: Franklin Watts, 1965. See
Chapter 10, "The Power of Thought."
- Davenport, Reuben Briggs. The Death Blow to Spiritualism. New York: G.
W. Dillingham, 1888. An attempt to write a true account of the
origins of spiritualism, approved by Maggie and Kate Fox.
Contains statements quoting them in respect to their fraudulent
practices.
- Dexter, Will. This is Magic: Secrets of Conjurers' Craft. New York:
Bell, 1948. See Chapter 14, "Is It Second Sight?"
- Doyle, Arthur Conan, The History of Spiritualism. New York: George H.
Doran Co., 1926. A sympathetic approach originally published at
the author's own expense. Conan Doyle was interested in
"phenomena for over 30 years." He says, "My one aim in life is
that this great truth, the return and communion of the dead,
shall be brought home to a material world which needs it so
badly." Conan Doyle's credentials as a researcher were often in
question especially when he attributed certain escapes of
magician Houdini to dematerialization. It should be said that
those who fault Conan Doyle as an investigator also pay tribute
to his total integrity and unimpeachable character. The same
cannot be said for Houdini in respect to his ego-centered psychic
investigations.76 Intriguing correspondence exists between the
author of Sherlock Holmes and the Escapologist in the book
Houdini and Conan Doyle, "The Story of a Strange Friendship" by
Bernard M. L. Ernst and Hereward Carrington published by Albert
and Charles Boni Inc., New York 1932.
- Dunninger, Joseph. Houdini's Spirit Expose: From Houdini's Own
Manuscripts, Records, and Photographs, and Dunninger's Psychical
Investigations. New York: Experimenter, 1928.
- Dunninger, Joseph. Inside the Medium's Cabinet. New York: David Kemp,
1935.
- Dunninger, Joseph, as told to Gibson, Walter B. Dunninger's Secrets.
Secaucus, N.J.: Lyle Stuart, Inc., 1974.
- Edmund Scientific Company Catalog 761. Barrington, N.J.: 1976. Within
the more than 4,500 items listed of a "scientific" nature are
items suitable to the fake medium, such as black light paint,
clear liquid that glows in the dark when applied to any surface,
and a kit to transfer pictures and photos to cloth surfaces, plus
other items from this supply house for industry, schools, and
hobbyists.77
- Edmunds, Simeon. Spiritualism: A Critical Survey. London: Aquarian
Press, 1966. Contains full account of exposed medium William Roy
and his methods.
- Evans, Henry Ridgely. The Spirit World Unmasked. Chicago: Laird and
Lee, 1897.
- Evans, Henry Ridgely. Hours with the Ghosts. Chicago: Laird and Lee,
1897. See methods used by the Davenport Brothers as originators
of the Spirit Cabinet.
- Fodor, Nandor.Encyclopedia of Psychic Science. New Hyde Park, N.Y.:
University Books, 1966. See "Fraud."
- Fodor, Nandor. The Haunted Mind. New York: Helix Press-Garrett
Publications, 1959. See chapter XVI, "Demon Lovers and
Mediumship."
- Frikell, Samri, Spirit Mediums Exposed. New York, New York
Metropolitan Fiction 1930. (Actually written by Fulton Oursler).
- Fuller, Uriah. Confessions of a Psychic, The Secret Notebooks of Uriah
Fuller, published by Karl Fulves, Box 433, Teaneck, New Jersey,
1975. A magician's view in booklet form of how fake psychics
perform seemingly incredible paranormal feats. This is an attempt
to speak for Uri Geller and to relate how he bends metal, reads
sealed drawings and apports objects. It also hints at the
possibility of Nina Kulagina in Russia having magnets in her bra
to move a compass and all the deceptive methods which may be
employed in what the author believes is the "underground of
deception." It makes the exaggerated claim that the only persons
qualified to examine self-claimed psychics are magicians
experienced in the "double think" or "lateral thinking" approach
to their craft.78
- Gaines, Steven S. Marjoe: The Life of Marjoe Gortner. New York: Harper
and Row, Publishers, 1973. The biography of a fake
evangelist.79
- Gibson, Walter B. The Bunco Book. Holyoke, Mass.: Sidney
- H. Radner, 1946. Methods of confidence men and schemers from games of
chance to short-changers.
- H. Radner and Young, Morris N. Houdini on Magic. New York: Dover
Publications, 1963.
- Gresham, William Lindsay. Nightmare Alley. New York: Rinehart, 1946. A
gripping novel of the rise and fall of a mind-reader.
- Hall, Trevor. The Spiritualists. New York: Helix Press, Garrett
Publications, 1962.
- Hardinge, Emma. Modern American Spiritualism. New Hyde Park, New York:
University Books, 1970. A twenty-year record of Spiritualism in
mid-nineteenth century America.
- Hill, J. Arthur. Spiritualism: Its History, Phenomena, and Doctrine.
New York: George Doran, 1919.
- Houdini, Harry. The Right Way to Do Wrong. An Expose of Successful
Criminals. Boston, Mass.: Harry Houdini, 1906.
- Houdini, Harry. "Houdini Exposes the Tricks used by the Boston Medium
`Margery'" New York: Adams Press, circa 1924. Known as the famous
"pink pamphlet."
- Houdini, Harry. A Magician Among the Spirits. New York: Arno Press,
1972. This book details the adventures of Houdini the
escapologist with spiritualists and mediums.80
- Houdini, Harry, and Dunninger, Joseph. Magic and Mystery: The
Incredible Psychic Investigations of Houdini and Dunninger. New
York: Tower Publications, 1968.
- Hoy, David. "The Bold and Subtle Miracles of Dr. Faust." Chicago:
Ireland Magic, 1963.
- Hull, Burling. "The Last Word in Blindfold Methods: 12 Sensational
Blindfolds." Woodside, N.Y.: Burling Hull, 1946. Privately
published.
- Hull, Burling. Thirty-Three Rope Ties and Chain Releases. New York:
Stage Magic, 1947. All a fake medium needs to know about the art
of rope-tying and release, including escape from a sack.
Privately published.
- Hull, Burling. Encyclopedic Dictionary of Mentalism, vol. 2. Calgary,
Alberta, Canada: Micky Hades Enterprises, 1973. A gigantic
collection of complete mentalism methods, secrets, instructions,
and routines.
- Jackson, Herbert G., Jr. The Spirit Rappers. New York: Doubleday,
1972. Letters, memoirs, court records, newspaper accounts, and
journals are cited in this story of Kate and Maggie Fox, founders
of the American Spiritualist Movement.
- Kaye, Marvin, The Handbook of Mental Magic. New York: Stein and Day,
publishers, 1975. An interesting book-- pretentious and self
important but interesting. The author calls himself Count Emkay
the Miraculous and has written a pompous and self centered
volume.81
- Kerr, Howard. Mediums and Spirit Rappers, and Roaring Radicals.
Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1972.
- Knight, Marcus. Spiritualism, Reincarnation, and Immortality. London:
Gerald Duckworth, 1950.
- Kreskin. The Amazing World of Kreskin. New York: Random House, 1973.
The author uses all the terms of parapsychology to lead the
reader into accepting his mentalism tricks as something more.
Allen Spraggett suggests that this book be retitled The Not-So
Amazing World of Kreskin.82
- Lawton, George. The Drama of Life after Death. A Study of the
Spiritualist Religion. New York: Henry Holt, 1932.
- Longridge, George. Spiritualism and Christianity. London: A. R.
Mowbray, 1926.
- Lustig, David J. La Vellma's Vaudeville Budget. For magicians, mind-
readers, mental telepathy, or silent thought transference.
- MacDougall, Curtis D. Hoaxes, New York: Dover Publications, lnc. 1958.
A book about ingenious deceptions and fascinating frauds. Note
Part I and II on incentives to believe and hoaxing in areas of
the historical, religious, scientific, literary and
governmental.83
- McHargue, Georgess. Facts, Frauds, and Phantasms: A Survey of the
Spiritualist Movement. New York: Doubleday, 1972. A
comprehensive and objective survey.
- Medhurst, R. G. Crookes and the Spirit World, in association with
K. M. Goldney and M. R. Barrington, New York, Taplinger Publisher
Company, 1972. The investigations by Sr. William Crookes, OM,
FRS, in the field of psychical research.
- Mental Catalogue. Box 476 Calgary, Alberta, Canada. Mickey Hades
Enterprises.
- Mental Magic and the Allied Arts. Catalog 28. Columbus, Ohio, 1966. (A
former company catalog of the world's largest manufacturers of
mental equipment.)
- Menotti, Gian-carlo. The Medium. New York: G. Schirmer, 1947. Opera
libretto.
- Morris, Bud. Magic with Electronics. Oakland, Calif.: Privately
published. Detailed methods of using microminiature electronics
as aids in apparent mind-reading; author also supplies such items
as subminiature wireless transmitters.
- Mulholland, John. Beware Familiar Spirits. New York: Charles
Scribner's Sons, 1938. Inside information on many of the methods
used by such mediums as Anna Eva Fay and Henry Slade.
- Nelson, Robert. How to Read Sealed Messages. Columbus, O.: Nelson
Enterprises, 1961 (mimeograph).
- Nelson, Robert. Secret Methods of Private Readers! Columbus, O.:
Nelson Enterprises, 1964 (mimeograph). How to give psychic
readings, switch billets and envelopes, and present private
psychological or cold readings. It begins with the private
reader's creed, "I like to see their eyes, mouth, and pocketbook
open at the same time."
- Nelson, Robert, and Moore, E. J. Super Prediction Tricks. Columbus,
O.: Nelson Enterprises, n.d. (mimeograph). All you need to know
to perform feats of prophecy, from predicting tomorrow's headline
to a sentence selected from a book in the local library and then
baked in a loaf of bread or frozen in a ton of ice.
- O'Donnell, Elliot. The Menace of Spiritualism. New York: Frederick A.
Stokes, 1920. This well-known writer of ghostbooks offers his
views on spiritualism with the Old and New Testaments in mind,
and has a chapter on the danger of fraud of all kinds.
- O'Neill, Tom. "The Tragic Deceptions in Materializations." Southern
Pines, N.C. Psychic Observer. July 10, Aug. 10, 1960.
- Pages from a Medium's Handbook. Calgary, Alberta, Canada: Micky Hades
Enterprises, 1971 (mimeograph). The ways and means of fake
mediumship, by an anonymous author.
- Pearsall, Ronald. The Table-Rappers. New York: St. Martin's Press,
1972. An excellent survey of Victorian Spiritualism. Contains
many methods of fraudulent practices citing those caught cheating
and how they did it.
- Pidgeon, Charles (pseud.). Revelations of a Spirit Medium. Edited by
Harry Price and Eric J. Dingwall, London: Kegan Paul, Trench,
Trubner, 1922. Facsimile edition, with notes, bibliography,
glossary, and index. This book was first published in 1891. Many
of the methods described are dated, but the general opinion
regarding "sitters" is still valid. Excellent glossary.
- Podmore, Frank. Mediums of the Nineteenth Century, vols. 1 and 2. New
Hyde Park, N.Y.: University Books, 1963. An indispensable account
of great mediums and the problems of research by "the most
formidable critic that Spiritualism has ever encountered."
- Price, Harry. "Regurgitation and the Duncan Mediumship." London:
Bulletin of the National laboratory of Psychical Research, 1931.
Believe it or not, the results showed that Mrs. Duncan could and
did swallow and regurgitate so-called teleplasm, which was merely
cheesecloth. Illustrations show, among other examples, how a
piece of cheesecloth six feet long, thirty inches wide, and
weighing 1 1/2 ounces can be rolled into a small wad and placed
in the mouth
- Price, Harry. Confessions of a Ghost Hunter. New York: Causeway Books,
1974. Chapter 15, "Stage Telepathy and Vaudeville henomena,'"
relates encounters and friendship with some of the great
spellbinders of all time.
- Proskauer, Julien J. Spook Crooks! New York: A. L Burton, 1932.
- Randi, The Amazing. The Magic of Uri Geller. New York: Ballantine
Books, 1975. A purported expose of Uri Geller. Funny in places
but unreliable.84
- Rauscher, William V. "ESP and Mentalism." Psychic. Vol. V, No. 4
(April, 1974): pg. 50.
- Rauscher, William V., with Spraggett, Allen. The Spiritual Frontier.
New York: Doubleday, Inc., 1975. See appendix on Houdini Code
Mystery Solved.
- Reilly, S. W. "Table-Lifting Methods Used by Fake Mediums."Chicago:
Ireland Magic, 1957 (mimeograph).
- Rinn, Joseph F. Searchlight on Psychical Research. London: Rider,
I954. A record of sixty years' work, with countless references to
methods of fraud.
- Roberts, Bechofer, C. E. The Truth about Spiritualism. London: Eyre
and Spottiswood, 1932.
- Robinson, William E. Spirit Slate Writing and Kindred Phenomena. New
York: Munn and Company Scientific American Office, 1898. The
author was associated with the famous magicians Alexander,
Herrmann, and Harry Kellar. He covers table-lifting, raps, ties,
and slate tests, including seance spirit tricks.
- Seybert Commission. Preliminary Report of the Commission by University
of Pennsylvania to Investigate Modern Spiritualism. Philadelphia:
J. B. Lippincott, 1887. Results are discouraging in this report,
presented as "one of the most thorough investigations of the
truth of Spiritualism ever attempted."
- Sommerlott, Robert. "Here, Mr. Splitfoot!" New York: Viking Press,
1971.
- Spence, Lewis. Encyclopedia of the Occult. New Hyde Park, N.Y.:
University Books, 1968. See "Fraud."
- Spraggett, Allen. The Unexplained. New York: New American Library,
1967. See Chapter 6, "Frauds and Teasers."
- Spraggett, Allen, with Rauscher, William V. Arthur Ford: The Man who
Spoke with the Dead. New York: New American Library, 1973. See
Chapter 6, "The Gospel of Spiritualism," Chapter 8, "Mentalists
and Mediums," and Chapter 11, "The Bishop Pike Affair."
- Stemman, Roy. Spirits and Spirit Worlds. New York: Doubleday and Co.,
1976. A sympathetic though critical book lavishly illustrated
with old and new photographs from the archives of Spiritualism.
- Tanner, Don. "How to Do Headline Predictions." Chicago: Ireland Magic,
1957.
- The Lambeth Conferences (1867-1948) Reports. London: S.P.C.K., 1948.
See report on spiritualism.
- Thurston, Herbert. The Church and Spiritualism. Milwaukee, Wis.:
Bruce, 1933.
- Tietze, Thomas R. Margery. New York: Harper and Row, 1973. An
intriguing account of the medium Mina S. Crandon, known as
Margery, and the perplexing events and personalities involved in
her seances at the Landon House on Lime Street in Boston,
Massachusetts,
- Whalen, William J. Minority Religions in America. New York: Alba
House, Division of the Society of Saint Paul, 1972. "The
Spiritualists," page 253, contains an account of a visit to Camp
Chesterfield.
- Dr. X. On the Other Side of the Floodlights: An Expose of Routines,
Apparatus, and Deceptions Resorted to by Mediums, Clairvoyants,
Fortune Tellers, and Crystal Gazers in Deluding the Public.
Berlin, Wis.: Heaney Magic, 1922.
- Zolotow, Maurice. It Takes All Kinds. New York: Random House, 1952.
See chapter 2 on Dunninger.
Additional Books and Sources recommended by the Anonymous Typist85
- The Skeptical Inquirer, magazine. Published by the Committee for the
Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal (CSICOP),
P.O. Box 703, Buffalo, NY 14226-0703. Subscription $25.00/year.
This quarterly magazine examines paranormal claims from
a scientific point of view. It has been criticized for being
too critical of the claims, but on the whole I've found it
to be a much-needed counterweight to the flood of
uncritically pro-paranormal literature out there.86 It's
probably the only magazine evaluating these claims from a
consistently criticla point of view.
The writing is sometimes a bit stodgy, and has to
strike a balance between scientific content (which turns off
many readers) and popular-science writing (which people
criticize for not being scientific enough). But there's no
other magazine like it, and open-minded people owe it to
themselves to take out a subscription.
from Prometheus Books, Buffalo, NY. Call 1-800-421-0351 for a free
catalog:
- Randi, James. The Truth About Uri Geller, Flim-Flam!, The Faith
Healers.
Enough has been said in these footnotes about Randi's
books and his history as an investigator, so anything I say
here would be redundant. Besides Gardner's books, they're
the most spirited attacks on paranormalism in print, and few
people are as qualified as Randi to examine these claims.
Essential reading.
- Frazier, Kendrick, editor. Paranormal Borderlands of Science and
Science Confronts the Paranormal.
These are althologies of the first ten years of The
Skeptical Inquirer. Good stuff,
- Marks, David, and Kammann, Richard. The Psychology of the Psychic.
Its scope may be narrower than most, but this is a
solid appraisal of the most spectacular psychic claims of
the mid-1970's. Two researchers at the Stanford Research
Institute claimed scientific proof of paranormal abilities,
such as Uri Geller's and Ingo Swann's remote-viewing. Marks
and Kammann tried to replicate the results, with no luck;
then they checked into what really went on during those
experiments, and found a history of stonewalling, fraud,
deceit, and just plain poor science. Even arcane and
technical issues are well-explicated in this book.
Other publishers:
- Gardner, Martin. Fads and Fallacies in the Name of Science, Dover
Books. Science: Good, Bad and Bogus. Avon Books, and
Prometheus Books.
The two best books to begin with.
- Abell, George O. and Singer, Barry. Science and the Paranormal.
Scribner's, 1983.
A good overview of various paranormal claims,
consisting of brief essays about everything from Velikovsky
to psychic healing.
- Randi, James. The Mask of Nostradamus. Scribner's 1990.
- Schultz, Ted, editor. The Fringes of Reason: A Whole Earth Catalog.
Random House.
The Whole Earth catalogs and its quarterly update
magazine frequently dealt with semi-paranormal and fringe-
science issues in a somewhat uncritical way; for example,
acupuncture and many brands of `Holistic' medicine were
recommended with little evaluation outside of New Age
encouragement. The one issue they did on the fringe-- from a
very criticial point of view, and where they turned around
and attacked many New Age beliefs-- enjoyed extremely high
sales, so they assembled this wonderful overview of the New
Age.
The book is more even-handed than the Skeptical
Inquirer, and demonstrates an empathy for the claims that
many skeptics miss. Essays include historical and
sociological insights that illuminate such curiosities as
Theosophy, Flat-Earthery, and even saucer-worship in a
broader social context.
- Stang, Rev. Ivan. High Weirdness By Mail. Publisher not known.
A hilarious collection of addresses for UFO fans, Jesus
contactees, Spiritualists, psychic readers, fringe
scientists, and lots of other cognitive flotsam. Stang's
commentary is wonderfully sarcastic, sparing nobody, and the
sheer scope of this work makes this a must-read.
- Sladek, John. The New Apocrypha. Stein and Day 1973.
Sladek assembled this well-researched overview of
fringe science just before CSICOP got underway, and in many
ways it's an indispensable guide. Interesting Historical
Note; After writing this, Sladek wrote a hoax astrology book
under the pen name `James Vogh,' claiming that there's a
thirteenth Zodiac sign (Arachne, the Spider). He managed to
fool a LOT of people with this one.
75. This book's okay, but only if you want to know how Houdini
effected his escapes.
76. Here we see Spraggett's grudge against magicians at the fore.
Conan Doyle was certainly sincere about his spiritualist beliefs; in
fact, he was so sincere that he even endorsed photographs of fairies
as genuine (in the Cottingley fairy hoax). Doyle was a rotten
investigator; he may have had an unimpeachable character, but that
just means he didn't lie about what he believed.
Houdini presents us with an intriguing picture. He was certainly
a skilled showman, and a case could be made for Houdini's exposures of
spiritualist frauds to be motivated by self-promotion. But Houdini
stated often that the reason he investigated so many fraudulent
mediums was so he could eventually find a genuine one-- so he could be
reunited with his mother, to whom he was devoted.
77. I grew up near the Edmund Scientific company, and, aside from a
phase during the mid-1970's when they were pushing pyramid power,
Edmund was consistently chock-full of neato-keen items of interest.
Call for their catalog-- it's worth flipping through for the REALLY
fun stuff.
That reminds me-- time to order some weather balloons for some
UFO hoaxes,
78. Now It Can be Told: Confessions of a Psychic was written by
Martin Gardner under the pseudonym "Uriah Fuller." As for the business
about magicians and psychics being an `Exaggerated claim,' we can
easily see Allen Spraggett's ego coming to the fore. Spraggett claimed
to be able to detect fraud-- but was unable to explain how James Randi
could duplicate some of Uri Geller's feats (see footnote, page ?).
Exaggerated claim? Actually, it's very close to the truth.
79. Available on videocassette is the documentary Marjoe, which is an
indispensable resource for anyone interested in faith healing and the
like. Marjoe Gortner was a child evangelist who left the sawdust trail
to try to make it as an actor. When that didn't work out, Gortner went
back to the tent-show healings. Only he brought along a camera crew to
expose the racket. Marjoe is a brave, honest, and revealing film about
religion in America.
80. An indispensable guide. Houdini was very much the scourge of
Spiritualism in his day, and this book is one of the best overviews on
the subject. The only drawback is in the chapter which describes how
mediums gain information on their clients. Houdini describes them
bribing intimates, using listening devices of the time, breaking into
houses and hotel rooms and the like. . . but he provides little
documentation on this. I have no doubt that Houdini was being honest
when he wrote this chapter; I just wish he could have cited more
detailed examples. Believe it or not, the book you're reading now is
more informative in this regard.
81. Oh, well, then.
82. Kreskin's always been a sort of anomaly among paranormal fans and
magic fans. Kreskin performs a `Mentalist' act, using magician's
techniques to simulate paranormal powers, and has never to my
knowledge used these tricks beyond showmanship. For example, Kreskin
hasn't been offering to help police departments find missing children,
or predict the best stock market investments.
However, he is somewhat evasive and contradictory in his public
statements as to whether such powers exist or not. A lot of people are
under the mistaken impression that he passes himself off as a genuine
psychic. All in all, Kreskin is just an entertainer, and to take his
pronouncements regarding psychic abilities and hypnosis with a grain
of salt. Just enjoy the show.
Martin Gardner, in Appendix 1, describes Allen Spraggett's weird
grudge against Kreskin.
83. The Anonymous Typist also recommends this book.
84. This book is now titled The Truth About Uri Geller, and is now
published by Prometheus Books, Buffalo, NY.
James Randi, as though you didn't know, is a professional
magician who has been investigating psychic claims for almost forty
years. Because he hasn't found any evidence of such claims-- and
because he's debunked some of the most notable claims in the field--
believers are quick to accuse Randi of unfair and biased methods.
History has, more often than not, shown Randi's conclusions to be
accurate.
One entertaining chapter is titled, "Alan Spraggett Throws Down
the Gauntlet, and Then the Towel." Spraggett invited Randi onto his
talk show ESP-Extra Special People, and demanded that Randi accomplish
the same miracles that Geller had performed-- bending spoons and
nails, reading the contents of a sealed envelope, etc.
After Randi demonstrated spoon-bending, Spraggett offered a
pseudo-explanation: "The spoon was bent as you were picking it up. . .
there is a stress point, and with a little bit of leverage, it
separates quite neatly."
"You mean, that's the way Geller does it?" Randi asked.
"No, that's the way you did it!"
"Oh. you say Geller doesn't do it that way?" And so on.
When Spraggett produced an opaque envelope containing a drawing--
pre-stamped, sealed with tape, and he claimed that the room he'd drawn
the picture in was guarded as well-- he demanded that Randi duplicate
just what Geller had. Geller had held the envelope for ten seconds,
and then duplicated the drawing exactly. Randi asked Spraggett, "But
would you be impressed enough to say I'm a psychic?"
"I don't know," Spraggett said.
"Wait a minute," Randi said. "You say that Uri Geller is a
psychic because he did this. Now, if I were able to do it, would you
say I'm a psychic?"
"You do it, and I'll say that the Amazing Randi has amazed me."
Which is more or less what happened; Randi duplicated the drawing
exactly, leaving Spraggett gasping for an explanation. . . and trying
to insist that, while Randi used trickery, Geller still used genuine
psychic powers.
Spraggett terms Randi's book `Unreliable' because it describes
how Spraggett has his balls handed to him on live TV.
85. Not to be confused with Mofo, the Psychic Gorilla.
86. The best analogy I can think of is pretty much in another
ballpark. I used to hear a lot of criticism that the PBS series South
Africa Now was far too left-wing. However, when considered against the
rest of PBS's news shows-- The McLaughlin Group, Firing Line, Wall
Street Week, Adam Smith's Money World and the like-- one realizes that
the marketplace of ideas has been skewed far to the right, and that
overtly left-wing shows just don't exist.
In other words, when literature on the paranormal is dominated
not only by the supermarket tabloids, but by a variety of New Age
magazines and the old war-horse Fate magazine, an arch-skeptical
stance is needed to provide just a touch of balance.
Appendix 1.
For the contents of Appendix 1, see Martin Gardner's book: Science:
Good, Bad and Bogus. It has a chapter (23) on Allen Spraggett's book
Arthur Ford: The Man Who Talked with the Dead, a reprint of a New
York Review of Books, May 3, 1973 and subsequent letters. As this
book is easily obtainable no part of it will be reproduced here.
Appendix 2.
Some books recommended by your distributor.
- Ruth Brandon, The Spiritualists. Buffalo: Prometheus Books, 1983.
- Brian Inglis, Natural and Supernatural. London: Abacus (Sphere
Books), 1979.
- R.L. Moore, In Search of White Crows. New York, 1977.
- Janet Oppenheim, The Other World - Spiritualism and Psychical
research in England, 1850-1914. Cambridge, New York: Cambridge
UP 1985.
- James Webb, The Occult Underground. LaSalle: Library Press, 1974.
- James Webb, The Occult Establishment. Glasgow: Richard Drew, 1976.
Both volumes of James Webb contain a wealth of material on
various occult organizations.
<<Prev Next>>