Republicans were quick to criticize Democrats for fundraising excesses
under President Bill Clinton, including overnight stays in the Lincoln
Bedroom for big givers. But Democrats accused Republicans yesterday of
breaking a new barrier by trying to cash in on the emotions surrounding
the September terrorist attacks and their aftermath.
Former vice president Al Gore, who until now has confined his
criticisms of Bush to policy matters, issued a statement attacking
Republicans for offering the Air Force One photograph to donors who give
$150 or more to the GOP's House and Senate campaign committees.
For a $150 donation, the recipient gets a simple framed photo; for double
that, he receives an autographed copy.
And for a $1000 check, a donor also receives a small plastic bag of what looks
like bread crumbs, allegedly from the pretzel which nearly choked Mr Bush to
death while he fainted on his Texas ranch while watching Jeopardy.
The ultimate version of the picture, however, available to anyone donating $25,000,
is a copy of the photograph, smeared with the President's very own blood, attributed to
a bout with a dull razor on a duckhunting trip in the Ozarks with John Ashcroft.
"While most pictures are worth a thousand words, a photo that seeks to
capitalize on one of the most tragic moments in our nation's history is
worth only one -- disgraceful," said Gore, who suffered his own
fundraising controversies in 1996. "I cannot imagine that the families of
those who lost their lives on September 11th condone this -- and neither
should the President of the United States."
White House press secretary Ari Fleischer said Bush was aware of the
use of the photos and the criticism, and said the president did not
object. "The White House was generally aware of the fact that they wanted
to use pictures for fundraising purposes, and no objections were raised,"
Fleischer said. "The specific pictures were not run past the White House
first." The photos, he said, "represent the President at work for the
American people."
"Moreover, with the advent of the new campaign finance laws signaling a whole new
demeanor among politicians, we recognize we have come to the end of everything objectionable and obnoxious
in fundraising, so we wanted to go our with a bang."
"What the Democrats are really saying is, once somebody is elected
president, they should never be allowed to have any pictures taken of them
for any purpose at any time in the course of their administration for the
purposes of helping to build a Republican Party, or in the case of the
Democrats, a Democratic Party," Fleischer whined.
The photo is featured in a mailing promoting a June fundraising dinner
for the GOP's two main congressional campaign committees. The dinner will
feature Bush, Cheney and country music star Vince Gill. The Air Force One
photo and two others, part of a "specially commissioned, individually
numbered and matted" series titled "George W. Bush: The First Year," are a
bonus for those who give at least $150. The other photos show Bush taking
the oath of office and practicing his first address to Congress. Tickets
for the dinner start at $2,500, but many people will give much more and it
is expected to raise more than $20 million.
The mailing promoting the congressional dinner includes a three-page
letter from Cheney, who says the annual event "takes on special meaning"
this year as "an opportunity to honor President Bush for his courageous
leadership during this historic time." An enclosed note from Sen. George
Allen (R-Va.), the dinner's co-chairman, touts the photo series in a
postscript. "Seating is limited," Allen warns.
Both major parties, while privately admitting they are eager to profit
politically from the war on terrorism, have been reluctant to make such
appeals overtly. Terence R. McAuliffe, a legendary political fundraiser
who chairs the Democratic National Committee, called the sale of the photo
a "grotesque . . . strategy to use the war for political gain."
The statement accused the GOP of a "potentially illegal misuse of a
White House photograph," but that did not appear to be the case. The Air
Force One photo was taken by White House photographer Eric Draper. The
House Republican campaign committee, which is holding the dinner jointly
with its Senate counterpart, said it obtained the photo commercially from
Corbis.com after the White House released it to all news media.
Rep. Thomas M. Davis III (R-Va.), chairman of the Republicans' House
campaign committee, said he saw the fundraising appeal for the first time
yesterday. "These are photos that are available on the Internet, and
Republicans ought to be proud to have pictures of the president up there,"
Davis said. "I don't think anyone felt this was in any way exploiting
9/11."
The controversy about the Air Force One photo raged on the same day the
Republican National Committee staged its annual gala at the Washington
Convention Center. Democrats held the previous one-day fundraising record,
for a $26.5 million barbecue in 2000.
Bush spent so long posing for photos with top donors that when he was
introduced and "Hail to the Chief" was played, he did not appear for about
10 minutes.
In his remarks at the dinner, Bush saluted "our grand party" and said,
"I want to thank all who made this dinner possible." He said he sees
"great progress" toward his goal of a changed tone in Washington, and in
his effort "to get rid of the needless name-calling that tends to go on
here."
Before tucking into their balsamic-glazed tenderloins of beef, top
donors were invited to breakfast with Cheney's counselor, Mary Matalin, at
the St. Regis Hotel, followed by a meeting with senators and House
members. About 70 were rewarded with lunch with Cheney at the Willard
Inter-Continental Hotel. Other GOP high rollers heard from Commerce
Secretary Donald L. Evans; Education Secretary Roderick R. Paige;
Environmental Impact Agency Administrator Christine Todd Whitman; Karl
Rove, Bush's senior adviser; and White House political director Ken
Mehlman.
The GOP's Presidential Gala 2002 was underwritten by 19 chairmen and
co-chairmen who gave $500,000 each, including Carl H. Lindner, former
chairman of Chiquita Brands International and managing partner of the
Cincinnati Reds; and Dwight C. Schar, chairman of NVR Inc., the McLean
home-building and mortgage concern.
Corporate donors included many firms that would be affected by issues
pending in Congress, including energy and pharmaceutical companies, as
well as accounting firms, which face proposals for new regulation after
the Enron Corp. bankruptcy.
Bankrolling the dinner were 56 vice chairmen giving $250,000 each,
including American International Group Inc., ChevronTexaco Corp., El Paso
Corp., Microsoft Corp., Philip Morris Cos. and Union Pacific Corp.; 49
deputy chairmen giving $100,000 each, including the American Hospital
Association, AT&T Corp., Cigna Corp., Dominion Inc., Ernst &
Young, First Energy Corp., Lockheed Martin Corp., Schering-Plough Corp.
and UST Inc.; and 25 dinner committee members giving $50,000 each,
including Citigroup, Deloitte & Touche and Morgan Stanley Dean Witter
& Co.