KILL 'EM ALL

This is a game i have been thinking of for a while, and have even started making in Klik before as a platformer, but now im not sure exactly what i will make it in yet, and that is why its in this section. It basically follows the story of Aaron from Felney as he escapes from a "research" facility dedicated to making gay people turn straight. Whatever it is made in i am planning to make it very gory and violent, complete with wounded enemies screaming for mercy and saying they'll never be homophobic again, before you slaughter them

Possible platforms:

Platform

Advantage

Disadvantage

Klik/MMF

Sidescrolling gameplay, could program in simple area-based gore system and wounding, and also a simple AI which would mean enemies could be confident, angry or terrified depending on what happens around them

Hard to program decent "enemy" platform AI, would have to make all of the frames and graphics ect mostly from scratch, having "realistic" maps would be a boring way to do it

DooM/EDGE

Most of the programming work done already (apart from the scripting), maps could be more interesting and realistic, using EDGE allows total customiseability over the weapons and enemies, as well as dynamic lighting. Lots of 'pre-made' graphics and sounds could be reused, for instance textures and weapon sprites

Would lack area-based gore system, wounded enemies would be possible, but it would happen at random. I'm not that good at scripting, though RTS seems simple enough, people would have to have DooM and EDGE to play it (well, one of those is a free download away)

SoF 2

Great graphics, the best gore system in a videogame so far, easily-done 3D realistic levels with scenery damage ect

I have no clue about 3D editing, or anything else involving SoF 2 editing for that matter

Klik/MMF 3D

Would be in 3D, would be able to have area-based gore systems, AI and other advantages of the Klik/MMF one

MMF3D is not out yet, i have no clue about 3D editing, though i suppose it would help me to learn about it for my 'main project', GTF