Caddy Fiero Swap Q & A Page:
Q. What transmissions fit the Caddy motor?
A. Four types: 4 speed manuals, % speed manuals (Isuzu and Getrag), the TH125 3 speed automatic, and the Caddy's
4 speed automatic. Note that these trannies come from "normal " Fieros; no Quad Four or OHC trannies (which
have an entirely different bolt pattern).
Q. Which is the easiest to adapt?
A. The Fiero 3 speed auto. The Caddy flex plate bolts right up, and the basic bolt pattern is the same. Some
clearance for the starter must be made by cutting away a portion of the transmission bell housing (which is true with
the manual trannies as well). Be sure to use the flexplate that came with your Caddy motor, for there for there's
a mix of internally/externally balanced flexplates out there. (All 4.9s have internally balanced flywheels.)
Q. Isn't that little 3 speed auto too weak to hold the Caddy's torque?
A. Actually, it has a higher torque rating than the Getrag 5 speed. Rebuilt and equipped with a shift kit it is
a solid unit. Gearing-obtained by altering the chain drive and differential gearing ratios-can produce final drive
ratios from 2.53:1 through 3.73:1. (Stock Fieros usually have 3.06:1 or 3.33:1 final drive ratios.)
Q. Why not just use the Caddy AOD automatic?
A. Many have. This swap requires different mounts and messing with the axles. (Need help here!) Some
of these units are computer controlled; others are not, so be careful. (See ECM difficulties.)
Q. How about using a manual trans?
A. The bell housing needs to be clearanced for the starter, and a custom flywheel obtained. Some have
welded the holes shut and re-drilled late V-6 flywheels for the Caddy crankshaft bolt pattern. A safer
solution would be to use a new, undrilled V-6 flywheel and have it drilled for the Caddy crank. (Only the
4.9 motors have internally balanced flywheels, so if you use an earlier Caddy motor you will have to get your
flywheel UNbalanced to match.) Finally, be aware that the final gearing on all Fiero manual transmissions
is fairly low. The Caddy motor, with its bags of low end grunt, is best served by the higher gearing available
only with the automatics.
Q. Will the clutch hold on to the Caddy's torque?
A. The small diameter of the Caddy flywheel area necessitates a small clutch and pressure plate. (Need help
here!) Probably the best choice here would be a Centerforce pressure plate. It uses centrifugal weights to
increase the spring force as the rpms rise. V8 Archie recommends this setup, and his S B Chevy conversions
make far more torque than a 4.9 Caddy.
Q. Which Caddy motors are recommended?
A. Avoid the 4.1 liter motors like a plague! They are powerless and, unless it's a later motor, not very reliable.
(It took Cadillac several years to get this radical, die cast motor successful. The later 4.5 liter motors, and
all 4.9s, are well developed and reliable.) The 4.5s are not as strong running as a 4.9. (Exception: Late
production 4.5 motors-identified by PFI injection and black valve covers, are in essence a 4.9 motor with a
short strike. This is a great engine!) Also available is the rare Allante motor with its long, tuned intakes (that
are reportedly good for another 20 horsepower). It's a keeper!
Q. How do I tell a 4.5 from a 4.9?
A. The engine size is cast into the block on the lower left side. Since this may not be evident (with the motor
in the car and/or filthy), the best identifier is the emissions sticker on the donor car. That said, 4.5s (and
the lamentable 4.1s) have straight valve covers (on the inside edge). All 4.9's have scalloped covers
that blend around the port injectors. One exception is the late 4.5 PFI motor which is virtually a 4.9 with
a short stroke.
Q. Which Caddy motors have the best performing heads?
A. The 4.9s (and similar PFI 4.5s). These heads have 1/4 inch larger intake and exhaust valves - a huge
increase! The 4.9 heads can be used on a 4.5 motor, and with either 4.9 or 4.5 intake and valve covers.
A 4.5 intake has differently shaped (and smaller) pods. They will still work, but maximum performance
when used with 4.9 heads will require a bit of porting.
Q. What compression ratio does a 4.9 have?
A. The 1985 version of the 4.5 motor had 8.5:1; later motors, and all 4.9s, have 9.0:1. It will run on regular
fuel (correct? Need help here!).
Q. I've heard these motors bearing knock like crazy?
A. All aluminum block motors are noisy. Early 4.x Caddy motors were especially knocky, so Caddy
tightened up the clearance on the front and rear mains. But that was to satisfy customer complaints,
not to keep the motors together.
Q. How about burning oil?
A. The ultra hard wet liners in these engines can go at least 150,000 miles without a trace of a ridge at the
top. (I challenge anyone to fine a ridge at the top of a Caddy liner!) So, if you are rebuilding a 4.x motor,
just hone her out and re-ring. The rings will seat beautifully, and the motor will be tight as new.
A word of warning: If the junkyard motor you are contemplating MAY have gotten water inside, then forget
it! the liners rust like crazy, virtually overnight, and the pits form will cause massive oil burning.
(Overboring the liner by.020 inches - for the largest pistons available - will not clean up a pitted liner.)
Find yourself a motor that's not a "submarine" and go with it instead. Trust me on this! (Fastjeff)
Q. What do I use to clean the motor prior installation?
A. A power washer with detergent will remove most of the crud, but deep cleaning requires a good solvent.
Castrol makes a good, water soluble, spray on cleaner that works fairly well - spray it on liberally, let is sit
overnight, then hose it off. The best cleaner for aluminum is carburetor cleaner. NAPA and others sell it
in gallon cans. Brush it on and let is sit overnight before hosing off (like the Castrol product).
Q. How about rebuilding one of these things; I've heard horror stories on how difficult it can be?
A. It is different, for the wet liners can move out of position when the heads are removed. (If the liners are
corroded in place, do not disturb them!) Either way, make up a flat washer and bolt deal to hold the liners
firmly in place as you hone and assemble the lower end. If the liners moved, then they must ALL be
removed. Mark the location and orientation of the liners on the outside with a pencil grinder (they're too
hard to stamp) and put them exactly back where they came from. Clean the block and parts thoroughly,
then reassemble the liners into the block with new O-rings and lots of silicone. Clamp the liners in place
with the heads (using old head gaskets) until the silicone sets. (And when it does, the liners are there to
stay. Forever.) Finally, a rebuilt caddy motor should always be pressure tested to be sure the liners are not
leaking.
Q. Yikes! Any more surprises I should know about?
A. Well, the head bolts are torqued in an odd patter, where three of the ten bolts are torqued more than the rest.
The female threads are in the aluminum casting, so these threads need to be cleaned thoroughly and coated
with a quality anti-seize compound. And be careful if you clean the threads with a tap, for they are not the
usual 12 mm pitch.
Q. How about motor mounts?
A. There's several ways to go here: use the stock Caddy mounts (on the sides of the block) with custom
brackets, or use a central mounting arrangement (similar to the Fiero setup) with a dog bone. (A1970s GM
Turbo 400 rear transmission mount makes a fine single front mount.) Both arrangements require custom
made parts (Bubba Joe sells the dual mount setup). In either case, the builder needs to make certain the
engine/trans is level with the cradle and parallel to the axle centerline. Use a long carpenter's level to be sure.
Q. Does the cradle have to come out to perform this swap?
A. Don't even think of doing this swap without dropping the cradle! With the cradle out of the car the engine,
the mounts and exhaust system can be rigged up with surprising ease. Each component of the drive train is
easily accessible, which is far from true when the cradle is back in the car.
Q. Can I service the Caddy motor in the car? It looks as if it would be impossibly tight?
A. Changing plugs is a pain, yet the plugs on both banks are accessible with ordinary tools - no trick sockets
and extensions required. The water pump is tough to change in the car (though it's not more difficult than
the V-6), so be sure it's right. Also, if your engine came from a car that took a front end hit, be sure to fill
and pressurize the block with water and check carefully for leaks before installing the motor. It doesn't take
much of a hit for the plate behind the water pump to leak like a sieve, and it's a dog to replace in the car.
Q. Will the battery need to be relocated?
A. No, but some have done it to make life easier (and to improve the front/rear weight bias).
Q. Will I need stiffer rear springs with Caddy V-8?
A. No, for a Caddy V-8 weighs virtually the same as the cast-iron 4 banger or V-6! This is a remarkable
achievement in motor design, one that has culminated in the awesome Northstar (a direct offshoot of the
4.x motor series, officially acknowledged as one of the ten best engines in existence).
Q. How about the engine control system?
A. First, decide what type of fuel system you want to use: TBI (which can be adapted to 4.9s as well), PFI
(port injection), a carburetor (2 or 4 Barrel), or some aftermarket fuel system (like a Holley Pro-Jection unit).
With the TBI or PFI system, the new ECM is installed in the console area (where the stock Fiero unit lives)
and wired through the firewall to the Caddy motor using portions of the donor car's wiring harness.
Q. Sounds kinda complicated. What's the simplest way to go?
A. A carburetor. Your fuel pressure must be reduced to about 5 psi with a fuel pressure regulator or the carb
will flood like crazy. The 4 banger fuel pump puts out approx. 13 psi, which most pressure regulators can
handle. The V-6, however, puts out close to 50 psi-more than most can handle. Instead of purchasing an
expensive, high-pressure regulator, build a simple by-pass "Tee" to reduce the fuel pressure before the
regulator. (this setup is recommended in any case to aid cooling of the fuel pump.) Finally, with a carb setup,
a centrifugal distributor needs to be made up from early Olds/Pontiac distributor parts. (This replaces the
ECM controlled distributor.) Hooking up this distributor is a breeze: simply reuse the Fiero's soil wires for
"hot" and "tach" and you're ready to go.
Q. But . . .doesn't the Fiero's ECM run the distributor?
A. True, but the poser (and tach signal) to this dumb distributor" is all you need to hook up. While we're on
this subject, the stock ECM runs very few operations in a Fiero. For example, the fans, cruise control,
speedo, oil pressure and voltmeter (both gages and lights) are all run totally independent of the Fiero's
ECM. (Signals go to the ECM for it to "know" what's going on. but it runs very little.)
Q. So, if I hook up this " dumb distributor", and use a carb, the ECM can be tossed out?
A. Yes, but you must sill run a wire from the Fiero oil pressure switch to keep the fuel pump relay engaged.
And you'll have to jumper the fuel pump relay to initially fill your carburetor bowl, for the fuel pump will
not run until the oil pressure gage sees oil pressure.
Q. How do I do this?
A. The easiest way is to jump the two vertical terminals (there are three terminals) in the switch connector.
Do it right, and you"ll hear the fuel pump running (if your CD isn't blasting).
Q. Why can't I simply rely on the oil pressure switch?
A. The switch is a temporary, get-you-home deal should the fuel pump relay burn out. Don't use this flimsy
oil pressure switch full time or you'll eventually get stranded somewhere. It's $45 part, incidentally.
Q. Is the stock Fiero fuel pump big enough to supply the Caddy?
A. Yes, unless you bypass way too much fuel back to the tank.
Q. Which carburetor works best?
A. The easiest, high performance setup is a Holley 500 cfm 2 barrel. (A Mr. Gasket 2 barrel - to - 2 barrel
adapter - $25 - can be bolted to the intake by merely drilling and tapping 4 holes. This Holley then bolts to
an adapter.) Another alternative is the lager-sized Rochester two barrel _vs. a similar looking but much
smaller unit) found on '70s and later GM cars. It flows about 320 cfm and is dirt cheap to buy. A custom
made adapter is necessary to bolt it up, however. A third alternative is a 4 barrel. This installation requires
extensive machine work to adapter it to the Caddy intake. Also, the length of the carb tends to interfere
with the alternator and other things on the relatively tiny Caddy intake.
Q. My car has to pass emissions testing, so what's my next choice?
A. EFI. The stock Caddy Ecm is and oddball monster that few have been able to tame. Its non-GM-like
programming is not easily adapted, and chip hackers will be of no help. By contrast, a common Chevy #7747
ECM can be adapted and "hacked" by anyone familiar with such efforts. Unfortunately, Chevy uses a different
idle control system from Cadillac (the Familiar IAC instead of Caddy's motor driven deal). That means a Chevy
TBI (or air throttle with MPFI) must be used (or some other arrangements made, like an external IAC system).
Finally, either TBI or a port injected Chevy ECM can be used.
Q. And that's all I have to do; just use the Chevy stuff and all is well?
A. Not really, for the fuel maps are not the same. Some tuning (via chip alteration) is necessary to convert the Chevy
functions to the smaller and different Caddy motor. (Need HELP here, Rockcrawl!)
Q. How about the radiator? Won't it be too small for a V-6?
A. The V-6 radiator, or the 4 banger with AC radiator, is okay, and even with A/C. (Toss out the tine, non-AC,,4 banger
radiator.) The Caddy motor uses an oil cooler that aids in cooling the engine. Most people mount the cooler,
which is essential, under an air grille.
Q. Can I retain my A/C?
A. Yes, but the pulley needs to be changed to a 7 groove type (and the lines lengthened??? Need help here)
Q. Any other belt drive changes needed?
A. The power steering unit is tossed out, along with the belt tensioner. To "turn the corner" another pulley is required:
a NAPA 7 groove pulley (part #38008). It can be bolted to the water pump housing with a 10 mm bolt and shimmed
to align the belt correctly. (This slick setup clears the rear hood hinge of the Fiero without cutting.) A NAPA
# 25-060810 belt is a good start in determining the right length belt, but a different length may be required for your setup.
Q. If I not using that tensioner, then how do I tension belt?
A. Most people pivot the alternator about the left side bolt and make up a sliding tensioner for the other side. Others
adapt the 4 banger alternator mount and eliminate the Caddy mount completely (with a sliding tensioner on the right side).
Q. Will the stock alternator, mounted on the stock bracket, clear the V-6 hood?
A. Yes, if your motor is installed level in the cradle. At least 1 inch of clearance will be available.
Q. How about the exhaust system?
A. Several options here, all of which require welding. Most people make up a custom cross over pipe that ties manifolds
together (in the rear), then goes to the stock Fiero exhaust location. (If you are using EFI, an O2 sensor bung must be
added at the junction.) The rest of the exhaust system can be stock Fiero, but a larger diameter (2 1/2 inch) is preferred.
A good shop can bend up a system that's similar to the stock system, but with larger catalytic converter, pipe and a free
flowing muffler. (Take your stock system to the muffler shop for them to copy. Tell them to leave slip joints in several places
for on-car adjustment.) You'll have to fashion pipe holding devices yourself, using the brackets removed from the stock
system, or custom exhaust brackets (available from J C Whitney and elsewhere).
Q. What if I want dual exhausts?
A. That's tougher to do, but still possible. The 89 Seville sent its left bank exhaust under the motor instead of crossing over to
the rear of the right manifold. Combining this left side dumb manifold with a non-Seville right side manifold provides dual
outlets (with rear cross-overs blocked off). Getting this nest of snakes out the back-two cats and two mufflers-may require
cutting out most of the trunk (though it CAN be done without depleting the Fiero's already meager trunk capacity). A good trick
is to use the steel (vs. cast iron)exhaust manifolds on 4.5 motors. Thses can be cut and welded to point the outlet in a more
friendly direction.
Q. How about the throttle linkage?
A. One has to use ingenuity to adapt the various throttle, crise control and (if used) throttle valve cables. On the later motors,
Caddy had to use something oddball, so be prepared for some heavy duty bodging.
Q. What is the easiest way to rig up a coolant outlet?
A. Weld the Fiero's thermo outlet to the Caddy outlet, or buy a Moroso inline radiator filler. (With the Moroso unit, be sure to
use a radiator cap with higher pressure than the one in front! And drill and 1/8 inch hole in your thermostat to allow the air
to get out.) It's a very good idea to use a safety cap in front-the kind with the lever on top. Not only is this far easier to open,
and keeps you from getting burnt, it allows easy "burping" of the cooling system.
Q. I've heard horror stories on how hard it is to put coolant in a Fiero. Got any pointers?
A. A piece of cake if you know the trick-and the Caddy installation is no different. With the Fiero's thermo housing setup, remove
the thermostat and fill the system. (Jacking the back of the car WAY up helps.) Fill the system to the top while opening the front
safety cap until coolant flows to the overflow tank. Then start the engine, and keep filling as the level drops. When it won't take
any more coolant, put the cap on (with the thermo still out). Run the engine 'til the left front radiator hose gets warm-that means
coolant is circulating-then shut her off. Carefully remove the rear cap (here's where the front safety cap is a blessing!), fill to the
top, add the thermo, and your done. With the Moroso setup, you do basically the same thing except that you have to patiently wait
for trapped air to exit via that 1/8 inch hole you drilled in the thermostat. (You DID remember to drill that hole, right?)
Q. How about hoses; what hoses can be used for the swap?
A. The 4 cylinder (outlet) hose can be massaged to work. A NAPA # 7865 hose with a section of pipe installed in its middle (ie; cut
the hose in half), works well for the inlet. You'll have to search for a molded heater hose with a 90 degree bend-a friendly auto store
is a plus here. The heater hose outlet in the thermostat housing-which is an oddball, oversized mess-can be tapped for a 1/2 pipe
thread. This allows a conventional heater hose fitting to be screwed in, one with a normal sized heater hose.
Q. My Fiero has the two speed rad. fan. Where will I put all of the Fiero temperature sensors I need to run the fan, Plus my ECM?
A. The Caddy thermo housing can be drilled and tapped (3/8 pipe thread) for up to 4 temperature sensors. Find a good spot
(that will not interfere with valve covers, etc.,) for the sensor, then drill and tap the housing. Be sure to locate a spot that's in a
flat area or you'll have problems.
|